Losing a loved one is difficult under any circumstances. But when someone passes away without a valid will in place, it can create confusion, delays, and disputes for the family they leave behind. In New York, these situations are governed by the laws of intestacy. This blog post explains how the legal process works when there is no will—who inherits, who handles the estate, and what steps are required to begin administration.
New York Law Determines Who Inherits When There Is No Will
When a person dies without a will (also called dying “intestate”), New York’s Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL §4-1.1) dictates how their property is distributed. The law identifies surviving relatives in a specific order of priority. If the decedent was married but had no children, the spouse inherits everything. If there are children but no spouse, the estate passes equally to the children. If both a spouse and children survive the decedent, the spouse receives the first $50,000 plus half the remaining estate, with the rest divided among the children. If no spouse or children survive, the estate may pass to the decedent’s parents, siblings, nieces and nephews, and so on. This distribution follows a strict statutory hierarchy and does not consider close friends, unmarried partners, or others outside the bloodline or legal relationship.
The Person Who Manages the Estate Must Be Appointed by the Court
When there is no will naming an executor, someone must petition the Surrogate’s Court to be appointed as the estate’s legal representative. This role is called the “Administrator.” Under New York’s Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act (SCPA §1001), the court considers applicants in order of priority. The decedent’s surviving spouse has the first right to serve, followed by adult children, grandchildren, parents, and siblings. If multiple people in the same class wish to serve, the court may appoint co-administrators or require waivers and consents from others with equal standing. If no suitable family member is available or willing to serve, the court may appoint the Public Administrator to oversee the estate.
Starting the Legal Process Requires a Petition and Supporting Documentation
To begin the administration process, the proposed administrator must file a petition with the Surrogate’s Court in the county where the decedent resided. The petition must include the decedent’s death certificate, a list of known heirs (called “distributees”), and an estimate of the estate’s assets. The court requires notice to be provided to all distributees, who have a right to appear in court and object to the appointment if there are concerns about the petitioner’s fitness to serve. Once approved, the court issues “Letters of Administration,” a formal document granting authority to manage the estate. This document allows the administrator to collect the decedent’s assets, pay debts, and ultimately distribute what remains.
Disputes Over Who Should Serve Can Lead to Court Challenges
Occasionally, family members disagree about who should act as the administrator. A distributee may object to another relative serving if they believe the person is unqualified—for example, due to dishonesty, addiction, mental incapacity, or a felony conviction. These concerns are governed by SCPA §707, which lists legal grounds for disqualification. A family member who objects must submit formal written objections, pay a filing fee, and may also file their own petition asking to be appointed instead. The court will hold a hearing if the parties cannot resolve the matter. In some cases, the court may appoint co-administrators or require a bond to ensure the proper handling of estate assets.
The Administrator Has Fiduciary Duties and Legal Responsibilities
Once appointed, an administrator acts as a fiduciary and is legally responsible for managing the estate in accordance with New York law. This includes gathering and inventorying assets, safeguarding property, notifying and paying valid creditors, filing required tax returns, and ensuring all financial obligations are satisfied before making distributions to heirs. If real estate must be sold, the administrator may need court approval. The administrator may also be required to file a final accounting detailing how the estate was managed. Failure to follow proper procedures can lead to personal liability.
Temporary Authority May Be Granted for Urgent Situations
In some cases, there is an urgent need for someone to act before full Letters of Administration can be issued—for example, if a property must be secured or bills must be paid immediately. A person may request “Temporary Letters of Administration,” which provide limited authority to take necessary actions during the interim period. These are typically granted for a fixed period, often up to six months, and may be subject to court-imposed restrictions or supervision.
Timeline and Costs Vary Depending on Complexity and Disputes
The time it takes to administer an intestate estate depends on several factors. Simple, uncontested cases can sometimes be resolved in a few months. However, if the estate involves disputes, significant debts, or assets that are difficult to value or transfer, the process can take a year or longer. Court filing fees are based on the value of the estate, and administrators may also need to pay for publication costs, bonding premiums, legal or accounting assistance, and appraisal fees. If disputes arise, litigation costs may significantly increase the time and expense of administration.
Options Exist to Resolve Disputes and Avoid Prolonged Litigation
If family members disagree over the administration of the estate, they may be able to reach an agreement by stipulation—such as serving as co-administrators or choosing a neutral third party to serve. These agreements must still be approved by the court but can help avoid drawn-out and expensive litigation. If no one is willing or qualified to serve, the court may appoint the Public Administrator, a government official who handles intestate estates, especially when no relatives come forward. However, this route can be slower and result in higher administrative fees being deducted from the estate.
The Best Way to Avoid Intestacy Is With a Thoughtful Estate Plan
The challenges of intestate administration can be avoided entirely by creating a valid estate plan during life. A properly executed will allows you to name an executor, choose your beneficiaries, and express your wishes clearly. For more complex situations, a revocable living trust or other estate planning tools can provide greater control, privacy, and efficiency. Estate planning also allows you to name guardians for minor children, reduce estate taxes, and avoid unnecessary conflict among heirs.
Conclusion
When someone dies without a will in New York, the legal process is driven by statute—not personal preference. The court must follow specific rules about who inherits, who manages the estate, and how everything is distributed. For surviving relatives, navigating this process can be overwhelming—especially during a time of grief. If you’re facing the task of handling an estate without a will, it’s important to seek legal guidance early on to ensure compliance, minimize disputes, and protect your family’s interests.
Need Help Navigating an Estate Without a Will?
At Mack Law, PLLC, we guide families through the complexities of intestate administration with clarity, compassion, and efficiency. Whether you need help filing for Letters of Administration, resolving disputes among heirs, or protecting estate assets, we’re here to help.
Contact us today to schedule a consultation and get the support you need to move forward with confidence.
This page is provided by an attorney for informational and educational purposes only. Its content is intended to offer a general overview of legal principles and should not be construed as legal advice. Viewing this page or interacting with its content does not create an attorney-client relationship. You should not act upon any information presented here without first seeking advice from a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction. Attorney Advertising.
Conclusion
When someone dies without a will in New York, the legal process is driven by statute—not personal preference. The court must follow specific rules about who inherits, who manages the estate, and how everything is distributed. For surviving relatives, navigating this process can be overwhelming—especially during a time of grief. If you’re facing the task of handling an estate without a will, it’s important to seek legal guidance early on to ensure compliance, minimize disputes, and protect your family’s interests.
.svg)
%201.webp)
.webp)
